Ohh…you read that right. There is a book with the title Wallbanger and it is worth reading! I had all intentions of posting this review before the dreaded “singles awareness day”, but my lovely little 6 month old had other plans for me. At any rate I finished Wallbanger the day after Valentine’s Day and have since been stewing and working on my review.
You see, dear readers, Wallbanger comes from an ever-increasing group of what I’m calling “fanfiction first authors”. Like Cassandra Clare (Mortal Instruments), E.L. James (50 Shades), and apparently this Christina Lauren woman (Beautiful Bastard) – Alice Clayton was a very famous fanfiction author before her novels were published. Said novels were also fanfiction first before having the names changed and being published. You can read my…opinionated reviews on these authors at your own leisure, but know that I do not hold Alice Clayton in the same category as those other fine ladies.
I really like Alice Clayton. She was always extremely nice to me in our email exchanges when Wallbanger was still a Twilight Fanfiction story. She also had no pretenses of hiding the fact she intended to publish using different names. Nor did she forget to thank the “banger nation” in her published novel. In my opinion she played the game extremely well, and I have nothing but respect for that.
That being said, I still can’t help but feel on the fence about this whole “fanfiction first author” situation. It’s not quite big enough to be gaining media attention but I feel like it might be changing the face of publishing. Well at least publishing in the romance novel genre. I have had conversations with my casual reader friends, my MFA friends, and even my husband and family and there doesn’t seem to be any kind of hot and fast reaction. What initially seems like disgust soon turns into begrudging respect, and what is initially indifference soon turns into misguided dollar signs. Just like the current state of Hollywood, anyone who isn’t a book/writing snob like me (self-proclaimed of course) seems to think I should be able to publish something because these women did. The brutal truth is I wish I had something worth publishing – but mostly for the same reasons I wish I had anything worth publishing. I want to be published, all writers do, but I think my hang up on the “fanfiction first author” publishing’s is this – it was fanfiction.
Fanfiction is something sacredly geeky. It’s the place you can escape to when you need to geek out about your beloved fandom without being made fun of. There is no judgment in fanfiction-land. There is something for everyone…and I mean EVERYONE. You can write about anything, you can make the characters do things you would never show to another soul, you can make all sorts of fandom’s intertwine and people BELIEVE it! It’s this magical place where you can be your best self and no one will shame you. Because even if someone does you just hide them and carry on in your own little world.
Having a novel that was beloved within fanfiction-land taken from us, doctored up for the mass media, and given (usually) a complete name change breaks that bond between writer and reader in this little world. Most unfortunate of all once these stories make it on to the written page they are pulled, in their entirety, from the Internet forever. I understand why this needs to happen but there is still a part of me that wishes I could go back and visit that story on the screen. There is a strange, feverish, all encompassing feeling when you see that your favorite online story has been updated. Perhaps knowing you can’t even reminisce of that by visiting the site anymore is what I miss most when these stories finally get to ‘the big show’.
All things considered I still really love Alice Clayton, and Wallbanger even more. My friend and I would have an absolute conniption fit every time we received the email that it updated. There would be a text message from one to the other with just one word: Wallbanger. All other things in our life stood still while we would read the chapter and then spend the rest of the day texting back and forth what we thought. It was a magical time. I am happy to report that the same magic has been captured again on the page with this publication.
The only critique I have, which was the same with the online version, is the last third of the novel. There is a bit of a pacing issue, as well as what I feel was forced drama for the sake of plot. As well as a level of believability at the end that even I could not look beyond, but it’s a romance novel so I’m not going to even go there. It is still a fantastic novel with authentic and likeable main and supporting characters. There is a fantastic use of show not tell for all the settings, and wicked sharp humor. And the banter….oh the banter. Alice Clayton is a master of banter. This novel will make you yearn fondly for the days of when you were wooed, or if you are single make you feel optimistic that decent guys still exist in this world.
I’m still not sure where I’m at with the “fanfiction first author” situation but if every author could have the same grace and talent as Alice Clayton I think publishing would be in a much better place. Read This Book!
My Rating: Four Stars
My Reasoning: Other than what I perceived as pacing, drama, and believability issues at the last third still an excellent book. The chemistry, the banter, and the writing are absolutely swoon-worthy. Must read for a steamy little treat.
My Recommendations: Single and taken ladies that need a little fire and romance in their life. Wallbanger is just what you didn’t know you were looking for.